top of page

Online Ordering

You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.

Not Accepting Orders
Min. order - $5.00

Our Cupcakes

All our cupcakes are made with better for you all natural ingredients. Check out our Our Ingredients page for more information. All buttercream is swiss meringue buttercream, which has a smooth, less sweet, more enjoyable taste than regular buttercream. You will thank us, or curse us, because you will never go back to regular buttercream again! Minimum order of a dozen cupcakes per flavor and 72 hour notice please. 1 week notice for larger or custom orders. $5.50 each.

Flavors

Decisions, decisions...Have fun picking!

Chocolate Madness

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache and topped chocolate buttercream. The chocoholic in you will thank you!

$0.00

Chocolate Madness

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate peanut butter ganache and topped with peanut butter buttercream. Who needs a Reese's?!

$0.00

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss

Chocolate Espresso

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate espresso ganache and topped with chocolate espresso buttercream. Is there any other better pairing?!

$0.00

Chocolate Espresso

Chocolate Salted Caramel

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate ganache and topped with salted caramel buttercream. Come on, need I say more?!

$0.00

Chocolate Salted Caramel

Chocolate Thin Mint

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate mint ganache and topped with chocolate mint buttercream. Let them eat the thin mints.

$0.00

Chocolate Thin Mint

Chocolate Meets Raspberry

Chocolate cupcake filled with chocolate raspberry ganache and topped with raspberry buttercream. The classic pairing your taste buds have been begging you for.

$0.00

Chocolate Meets Raspberry

German Chocolate

Chocolate cupcake with coconut pecan filling topped with chocolate ganache, caramel, and chocolate buttercream. You will never go back to classic german chocolate cake again.

$0.00

German Chocolate

Plain Jane You Say

Vanilla cupcake filled with white chocolate ganache and topped with vanilla buttercream. Basic, but we won't make fun of you.

$0.00

Plain Jane You Say

Ciao Cannoli

Vanilla cupcake filled with cannoli filling and mini chocolate chips and topped with vanilla buttercream. Get your Italian on!

$0.00

Ciao Cannoli

Confettilicious

Rainbow sprinkles (all natural of course) vanilla cupcake filled with white chocolate ganache and topped with vanilla buttercream and tons of rainbow sprinkles. Yay for confetti fun!

$0.00

Confettilicious

Toasted Coconut Marshmallow

Vanilla cupcake filled with coconut cream and topped with coconut marshmallow buttercream and toasted coconut. It's like you are on a tropical island.

$0.00

Toasted Coconut Marshmallow

PB&J

Vanilla cupcake filled with white chocolate strawberry ganache and topped with strawberry and peanut butter buttercream swirl. Takes you back to school...only better because no homework!

$0.00

PB&J

Luscious Lemon

Lemon cupcake filled with lemon curd and topped with lemon buttercream. Pucker up!

$0.00

Luscious Lemon

Our Cakes

All our cakes are made with better for you all natural ingredients. Check out our Our Ingredients page for more information. All buttercream is swiss meringue buttercream, which has a smooth, less sweet, more enjoyable taste than regular buttercream. You will thank us, or curse us, because you will never go back to regular buttercream again! 72 hour notice please. Custom cakes available, please contact us for pricing. 1 week notice for larger or custom orders.

The Usual Suspects

Perfect for any occasion. We go big with 3 layers of cake and 2 layers of filling and buttercream (unless noted otherwise) and finished with frosting. Comes with custom message or plaque. Available in 3 sizes. 8" - $75, 10" - $95, 12" - $120

Chocolate Madness

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate ganache and chocolate buttercream and frosted with chocolate buttercream. The chocoholic in you will thank you!

$0.00

Chocolate Madness

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate peanut butter ganache and peanut butter buttercream and frosted with peanut butter buttercream. Who needs a Reese's?!

$0.00

Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss

Chocolate Espresso

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate espresso ganache and chocolate espresso buttercream and frosted with chocolate espresso buttercream. Is there any other better pairing?!

$0.00

Chocolate Espresso

Chocolate Salted Caramel

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate ganache, salted caramel, and salted buttercream frosting and frosted with salted caramel buttercream. Come on, need I say more?!

$0.00

Chocolate Salted Caramel

Chocolate Thin Mint

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate mint ganache and chocolate mint buttercream and frosted with chocolate mint buttercream. Let them eat the thin mints.

$0.00

Chocolate Thin Mint

Chocolate Loves Raspberry

Chocolate cake layered with chocolate raspberry ganache, raspberry preserves, and raspberry buttercream and frosted with raspberry buttercream. The classic pairing your taste buds have been begging you for.

$0.00

Chocolate Loves Raspberry

German Chocolate

Chocolate cake filled layered with coconut pecan filling, chocolate ganache, and caramel, and topped with chocolate buttercream. You will never go back to classic german chocolate cake again.

$0.00

German Chocolate

Plain Jane You Say

Vanilla cake layered with white chocolate ganache and vanilla buttercream and frosted with vanilla buttercream. Basic, but we won't make fun of you.

$0.00

Plain Jane You Say

Ciao Cannoli

Vanilla cake layered with cannoli filling and mini chocolate chip, and frosted with vanilla buttercream. Get your Italian on!

$0.00

Ciao Cannoli

Confetti Fun

Rainbow sprinkles vanilla cake layered with white chocolate ganache and rainbow sprinkles vanilla buttercream and frosted with rainbow sprinkles vanilla buttercream. Yay for confetti fun!

$0.00

Confetti Fun

Toasted Coconut Marshmallow

Vanilla cake layered with coconut cream and coconut marshmallow buttercream and topped with coconut marshmallow buttercream and toasted coconut. It's like you are on a tropical island.

$0.00

Toasted Coconut Marshmallow

PB&J

Vanilla cake layered with white chocolate strawberry ganache, strawberry preserves, and strawberry and peanut butter buttercream and frosted with peanut butter buttercream. Takes you back to school...only better because no homework!

$0.00

PB&J

Luscious Lemon

Lemon cake layered with lemon curd and lemon buttercream and frosted with lemon buttercream. Pucker up!

$0.00

Luscious Lemon

The Make Over

Looking for that wow factor? Then these are the cakes for you. The designs are a bit more special than The Usual Suspects. All The Usual Suspects flavors available. Comes with custom message, sign, or plaque. Available in 3 sizes. 8" - $120, 10" - $165, 12" - $220

Rosette Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

2 tiers covered in rosettes. A beautiful, trendy, and feminine presentation.

$0.00

Rosette Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

Flower Border

Any of our the Usual Suspects cakes topped with a buttercream flower border to give your cake that extra special feeling.

$0.00

Flower Border

Drip Make Over Cake

Ganache drip and topped with lots of fun stuff (changes depending on the cake). This is a fun, funky, and trendy design cake sure to please anyone.

$0.00

Drip Make Over Cake

Tier Me Up, Scotty

These cakes are extra special with 2 tiers, giving you an even bigger wow factor than The Make Overs. All The Usual Suspects flavors available. Comes with custom message, plaque, or sign. Available in 2 sizes. 10"/8" - $210, 12"/10" - $265. Add The Make Over (choose from any of The Make Overs, and we will apply the design to the tiered cake). 10"/8" - $310, 12"/10" - $415

Tier Me Up 10"/8"

10" bottom cake with 8" top tier.

$0.00

Tier Me Up 10"/8"

Tier Me Up 12"/10"

12" bottom cake with 10" top tier.

$0.00

Tier Me Up 12"/10"

Rosette Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

2 tiers covered in rosettes. A beautiful, trendy, and feminine presentation.

$0.00

Rosette Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

Flower Border Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

2 tiers with a buttercream flower border to give your cake that extra special feeling.

$0.00

Flower Border Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

Drip Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

2 tiers with ganache drip and topped with lots of fun stuff (changes depending on the cake). This is a fun, funky, and trendy design cake sure to please anyone.

$0.00

Drip Make Over Tier Me Up Cake

Our Cookies

All our cookies are made with better for you all natural ingredients. Check out our Our Ingredients page for more information. 72 hour notice please. 1 week notice for cookie platters or larger orders.

Signature Giant Stuffed Cookies

Signature Giant Stuffed Cookies

These cookies are GIANT, measuring a minimum of 4.5" in diameter and STUFFED with all kinds of goodness. Prices are per each cookie.

Triple Chocolate Hazel Nutter

Holy oversized stuffed deliciousness batman! Crispy on the outside and soft gooeyness on the inside, these triple chocolate chip (you read that right) cookies are stuffed with Nutella and topped with just the right amount of salt and more chocolate chips of course. A perfect combination. I've been told these are award winning. Ok, so it was my brother who said that, that still counts right?!

$5.00

Triple Chocolate Hazel Nutter

More S'mores

While our More S'mores Cookie isn't as messy as an actual smore's, we do promise gooey wonderfulness none the less. Triple chocolate chip cookie stuffed with gooey marshmallow, rolled in graham crackers, topped with gobs of mini marshmallows, graham cracker pieces, and chocolate chips and hand torched for that S'mores taste.

$5.00

More S'mores

White Truffle Pistachio

We went outside the box here with this combo, ugh, or inside the cookie, whatever. Brown sugar cookie packed with tons of pistachios and white chocolate chips and stuffed with white chocolate truffle.

$5.00

White Truffle Pistachio
Italian Cookies

Italian Cookies

These cookies are nod to my Italian heritage and baker grandfather. You won't be disappointed. Why choose just one? Why not choose like Cookie Monster is your life coach? Prices are per dozen cookies.

Anginettes (Anginetti) Anise (Anisette) Cookies

Another classic Italian cookie. These beautiful balls of tender but denser anise flavored (black licorice taste) cookies are covered in a sweet anise glaze and all natural sprinkles (sprinkles can vary). Perfect with some coffee, or anytime really, and these dangerously easy mouth popping treats take you back to Nonna time!

$15.00

Anginettes (Anginetti) Anise (Anisette) Cookies

Pignoli Cookies

An Italian classic but we have a signature recipe that has passed the test (hardcore old school Italian taste buds!). Be prepared for addiction. Almond cookies with pignoli (pine) nuts. Approximately 2" in diameter each.

$29.00

Pignoli Cookies

Pistachio Cranberry Biscotti

These twice baked Italian cookies are crisp enough to be dipped in your favorite beverage yet tender enough to be eaten alone. Packed with pistachios and cranberries and dipped in white chocolate.

$30.00

Pistachio Cranberry Biscotti
Cookie Platters

Cookie Platters

Have a special occasion or function coming up and need a cookie fix? We got you covered with our jam packed cookie platters.

Cookie Platter Large

Platter containing a variety of our cookies. Can customize cookies but may be upcharge additional cookies of more expensive varieties. Picture is just an example of a recent cookie platter and not a guarantee it will be same.

$90.00

Cookie Platter Large
"Normal" Sized Cookies

"Normal" Sized Cookies

Looking for smaller cookies to tackle your craving and share the love? No problem, our "normal" sized cookies are made for just that. Why choose just one kind? Why not choose like Cookie Monster is your life coach? Prices are per dozen cookies.

Peanut Butter Blossoms

Classic but delicious and a perfected recipe for minimal cookie spread for fluffy, tender goodness. Maximized peanut butter for a big peanut butter flavor cookies with a sugar coating and topped with a Hershey's kiss.

$18.00

Peanut Butter Blossoms

Lemon Raspberry Thumbprints

A little twist on a classic thumbprint cookie. Bursting with lemon cookie with raspberry preserve and Chambord center topped with a drizzle of glaze for just a little sweetness.

$20.00

Lemon Raspberry Thumbprints

© 2018 by PURE GOODNESS BAKERY. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page